Tonight's fight got me thinking about boxers who have overextended their careers. There's quite a litany of aging greats who could qualify for such a list. I've narrowed this one down to five. I've excluded fighters like Margarito and Larios who are already barred from fighting in the U.S.
So let's say the boxing Gods have granted you the ability to permanently retire any one boxer. Who would you choose?
Which of the following fighters would you most like to see retire and never come back?
Marco Antonio Barrera (26 votes)
Roy Jones Jr. (38 votes)
Evander Holyfield (153 votes)
James Toney (27 votes)
Oscar De La Hoya (48 votes)
other (please explain) (2 votes)
294 total votes