Vic Darchinyan knocked back, but not out
Something in boxing has been unfortunately pushed onto the back burner this week, but it deserves serious discussion.
Now that Vic Darchinyan's win streak is over, where does he go? How is he viewed? What's his new standing?
Count me among those that got on the Darchinyan train in a big way after his destruction of Cristian Mijares last year, a fight that was seen as a major upset at the time. Not only was Darchinyan the underdog, but most talked about the bout being a no contest, about Mijares inevitably using his slickness, skill and speed to frustrate and perhaps even toy with Darchinyan, a loose-armed brawler whose tactics just didn't add up against the classy Mexican.
Not the case. Darchinyan steamrolled him as he had done Dmitri Kirilov, and as he would do months later to Jorge Arce. Armenia's "Raging Bull" was on top of the world.
Darchinyan was in my top 10 pound-for-pound, and in most others', too. He was one of the sport's hottest fighters. His promoter, Gary Shaw, couldn't have sounded more ecstatic. Onward and upward, Gary proclaimed, and we went for the ride. I wondered how high Darchinyan could go. With a fairly weak bantamweight division awaiting him, Darchinyan and Shaw talked about moving up to 122 pounds quickly, maybe even further.
Joseph Agbeko put dreams on hold by beating Darchinyan this past Saturday, and Vic Darchinyan has no one to blame but himself for that loss. It was a rough, dirty fight, and though Darchinyan came out of it looking far worse for wear, he was in it, contrary to the incredibly biased commentary from Showtime's Al Bernstein and Gus Johnson. In fact, had Darchinyan actually fought the 12th round instead of allowing Agbeko to coast to the finish line, he likely would have escaped with a controversial split decision victory. He lost by one point on two of three scorecards, as well as our unofficial Bad Left Hook card.
Now we're talking about the nitty gritty of where Darchinyan's career is going.
We can now examine his recent hot streak more fairly, as is the case with any fight. Once you see what happens after, you can often tell more about what it all really meant. After he was destroyed by Nonito Donaire -- Darchinyan's first pro loss -- in 2007, Darchinyan got back on the horse. He beat Federico Catubay in a rebound bout, then drew Z Gorres in a horribly officiated debacle in the Philippines. The win over Kirilov was solid and dominant, the win over Mijares doesn't look as good now as it did then, and the win over Arce remains credible but unspectacular.
But it wasn't just the resume. It was the force with which he was handling these guys. None of the latter three even stood a chance against Darchinyan those nights. He smoked them all.
Agbeko was another story, and I think we all knew that. I had trouble picking the winner beforehand, and I went with Darchinyan because I believed him to be a top 10 pound-for-pound fighter who could handle the three-pound jump well enough to deal with a gritty, good fighter. But no one thought this was a pushover, or at least they shouldn't have.
What doomed Darchinyan against Agbeko was a horrid execution of gameplan. His corner begged and pleaded with him to jab, and he refused. Instead, he found himself trying to flail away at Agbeko, who was big and strong enough to take some solid shots from Vic without so much as flinching. Agbeko, on the other hand, rattled Darchinyan's cage on more than one occasion, and he found a home for a lead right hand and a frankly subpar left hook all night. Agbeko is no hooker -- a guy with a better left hook would have put Darchinyan to sleep in that fight. It's exactly how Donaire was able to do it.
It now seems foolish to consider the idea of Darchinyan against Israel Vazquez, for instance. I was willing to semi-write off the Donaire loss as a bad night from which Darchinyan learned valuable lessons, but you get him arrogant and rolling again, and he makes the same bad, ugly mistakes he did against Donaire.
Darchinyan against Agbeko was night and day compared to how he handled Arce, Mijares and Kirilov. It was like he abandoned everything that had made him such a dangerous, well-rounded fighter and went back to all that video game, crab-shuffling, wild-punching brute stuff that got him knocked silly against Donaire. You could see Darchinyan grow considerably frustrated during the fight, not just with Agbeko's roughhouse tactics, but by his own inability to back up his big mouth. It's rare that someone shuts Darchinyan up.
So what now? Where does he stand?
I still think he's a top 20 pound-for-pound fighter. He lost a close fight against a good opponent while moving up in weight. If he stays at 115 pounds, there's a fight now: Nonito Donaire. There's even a decent reason to consider rematching Agbeko. On a better night, Vic beats him at 118. Not easily, but he beats him. I still think he's a better fighter if he executes, but he didn't.
Gary Shaw's wild-eyed visions of Darchinyan glory will have to be cooled for the time being, but there's still a lot for him to do. He could try to avenge either defeat. He could look for something else, I suppose, though there's not a ton out there at 115/118, and at 33, he's no spring chicken.
As much as I feel somewhat let down by Darchinyan's performance, I don't count him out. The Donaire loss was ten times worse and he rebounded from that in fine fashion. And I don't expect him to go looking for creampuff opponents, either. He's too proud, too arrogant, and too ambitious for that.
0 recs |
13 comments
|
Comments
Gotta comment on this...
“In fact, had Darchinyan actually fought the 12th round instead of allowing Agbeko to coast to the finish line, he likely would have escaped with a controversial split decision victory. He lost by one point on two of three scorecards, as well as our unofficial Bad Left Hook card.”
So apparently you’re counting the BS “knockdown” the Darchinyan scored? Please, Vic is a great fighter when he’s not in brawler mode like he was during this fight. Agbeko peppered him with lead rights all night and Vic spent most of the night swinging wildly. Vic was only IN this fight in the middle few rounds when Agbeko seemed to slow down.
The final cards shouldn’t have been as close as they were, not even counting the BS knockdown.
by DarienRA on Jul 14, 2009 9:27 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Rules are rules
If a knockdown is called, you have to take it into account, BS or not BS.
Personally, I scored that round 10-9 Darchinyan, as I though Agbeko won the rest of the round.
Bad Left Hook - The SB Nation boxing blog
"Baseball is played on the field, not on a calculator."
by Brickhaus on Jul 14, 2009 10:27 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I’m counting the knockdown because it was called, BS though it pretty much was. Ringside judges don’t get to watch the replay directly after, they have to rely on the idea that the referee did the right thing.
Agbeko won this fight. I’m not saying he didn’t, or that he didn’t deserve to. But the cards say that if Darchinyan hadn’t done nothing in the 12th round, he probably would have wound up getting out of there with a win that a lot of folks disagreed with.
by SC on Jul 14, 2009 2:45 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Fair enough. As an extended discussion that my wife and I constantly have while watching boxing it really makes no sense that the ref’s aren’t able to view instant replay in between rounds to verify a knockdown is legit.
by DarienRA on Jul 14, 2009 4:21 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Instant replay in boxing has come up a lot. So many bad knockdown calls happen, and so many bad calls where a cut is ruled from a headbutt when it was a punch, etc. It’s just a matter of getting things right. I get wanting to keep the human element, but sometimes things get really boned in the process.
by SC on Jul 14, 2009 5:06 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Agreed
It seems like something relatively simple to do. A lot better than open scoring.
Bad Left Hook - The SB Nation boxing blog
"Baseball is played on the field, not on a calculator."
by Brickhaus on Jul 14, 2009 5:23 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Unofficial BLH scorecard
SC and Brickhaus, do you guys colloborate on this card?
by FunnyBigHat on Jul 14, 2009 7:12 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
No, Scott is official
I’m unofficial (unless Scott is taking the night off), but I still had Agbeko winning 115-113. A lot of people give their scores in the fight threads. I guess my score on Cruz-Solis was “official” though.
Bad Left Hook - The SB Nation boxing blog
"Baseball is played on the field, not on a calculator."
by Brickhaus on Jul 14, 2009 7:44 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I go back and forth on official/unofficial. The BLH scorecard (either way) is just whichever of us did the RBR.
by SC on Jul 14, 2009 10:25 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
DONAIRE'S WAITIN
Nonito has been waiting for you, Vic. Get your beating over with so you can retire on your Florida beach.
SPEED, ACCURACY, HEART = DEATH TO ALL WHO OPPOSE
by TNTLEFTHOOK on Jul 14, 2009 9:33 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
A rematch with either should be made soon maybe after a rebound fight
"Good, so it can’t go any deeper." - Arturo Gatti after being told he was cut to the bone
by sigidy on Jul 15, 2009 1:37 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I wouldn’t mind him taking his IBF mandatory and then going after one or the other. Donaire could be done at 115, Agbeko again at 118. I don’t see Nonito or Agbeko getting a bigger opponent, either.
by SC on Jul 15, 2009 6:05 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 














