Khan vs Peterson: Amir Khan's Five Best Wins
Amir Khan's fight on Saturday night against Lamont Peterson will be one of the biggest and toughest of his young career, which has seen him go from hyped amateur and Olympic silver medalist, to top British prospect at 135 pounds, to a career nearly in ruins after a 54-second knockout at the hands of Breidis Prescott, and finally, to a titleholder and one of the best in the world at 140 pounds under the tutelage of Freddie Roach.
Khan has rubbed many the wrong way over his career, but has also picked up fans all over the world. His talents are obvious, but his shaky chin leaves many skeptics -- and makes his fights against guys who can punch all the more interesting, because you just never know when he might get caught.
Now Khan looks to close out his run at 140 pounds with an impressive win over a legitimate contender, and then move to the welterweight division, where he plans to chase a 2012 fight with Floyd Mayweather Jr.
[ Related: Khan vs Peterson Press Conference Video ]
Let's look back on Khan's five best wins. They're all in the junior welterweight division, since he did little of note at 135 (sorry, anyone who thinks his defeat of a shot, overweight, and injured Marco Antonio Barrera was impressive).
5. Paul McCloskey (2011-04-16)

(Photo by Alex Livesy/Getty Images)
McCloskey came in undefeated, the European junior welterweight champion, and was on fairly equal footing crowd-wise in Manchester against Khan, making the fourth defense of his WBA title. McCloskey was also somewhere in or around the back end of the top ten at the time, but was not considered any huge threat to Khan -- you'll get the notion right now that, for the most part, Khan has really done nothing spectacular so far, but has had a solid career at 140 that gets better on Saturday. If Khan wins Saturday, the Peterson fight immediately jumps to at least No. 3 on this list.
Khan and McCloskey both fought quite poorly in this one, with Khan especially looking jittery and out of sorts, not landing with the accuracy he usually had in recent fights and just looking a step or two off-center for much of the fight. That said, his activity pretty much muted McCloskey, who did little more than mug with his arms at his sides and get cut, leading to a technical decision after six rounds, all of which Khan won.
4. Zab Judah (2011-07-23)

(Photo by Scott Heavey/Getty Images)
After a couple months of trash talk and some drawn-out negotiations, Khan met with veteran American Judah in Las Vegas to unify his WBA belt with Judah's IBF belt, which Judah had picked up in a struggle with the mediocre Kaizer Mabuza in March. Judah's whole game at this point was talking about how much he'd changed, how he wasn't the old Zab anymore, and how he was "back" as a top fighter.
As usual, he was the same old Zab in the pre-fight hype, talking as much trash as anybody, and his promises to look like the mythical Judah of yore were just promises he couldn't keep. He was once again more sizzle than steak, as Khan bullied him around for for rounds before finishing him off with a body shot in the fifth. Judah and his defenders continue to cry about a low blow, but even if it were extremely low (it was borderline at worst), Judah should have known to get up instead of sitting and talking to a counting referee. His excuses were empty, and all that came of this fight was disappointment to the believers who thought it would be anything more.
The biggest reason that this fight ranks over the McCloskey win is that Khan himself looked in terrific shape and dominated the fight. It's really not much to do with Judah being better than McCloskey anymore, though he probably is by a fairly narrow margin.
[ Related: Roach Says Peterson Will Be Toughest Test Yet ]
3. Paulie Malignaggi (2010-05-15)

(Photo by John Gichigi/Bongarts/Getty Images)
Malignaggi has always been more heart than anything else, and that includes flash, brashness, and "swagger." While the colorful and loud New Yorker has put together a damn fine career, he has always fallen short in his true biggest fights and tests, and that was the same case against Khan that it had been against Miguel Cotto and Ricky Hatton.
But that doesn't mean it wasn't an entertaining fight. No longer as nimble as he used to be, Malignaggi was forced to trade shots with Khan at various points, and given Paulie's lack of power, it was never going to be a question of the outcome.
Lamont Peterson recently summed up this particular matchup in a nutshell: "To me, Malignaggi will never beat Khan. It's just a bad style matchup for Paul. All the things that Paulie does, Khan does better. At that point, he'll probably never win the fight."
Paulie gave it his all, but was stopped by referee Steve Smoger halfway into the 11th round.
2. Andriy Kotelnik (2009-07-18)

(Photo by John Gichigi/Getty Images)
Khan's first fight at 140 pounds was a title fight. It's good to have the right connections sometimes, and Frank Warren made this one happen, just before Amir skipped off to Golden Boy Promotions. Putting the stunning loss to Breidis Prescott and the 135-pound division firmly in his rear view mirror, Khan dominated the very solid Kotelnik over 12 rounds, winning a decision on scores of 120-108, 118-111, and 118-111. Kotelnik had no answers for Khan's speed, reach, and confident game plan provided by Freddie Roach. Khan made it look easy, and it wasn't.
In a recent interview on the MMA Nation radio show with Luke Thomas, Peterson said he felt that Kotelnik was Khan's greatest victory to date: "Kotelnik is a really good fighter that I respect. Khan kind of won the fight pretty easy, and I was surprised at that. That's probably his biggest win. I expected Khan to come out (fast), but I expected him to burn out, and for Kotelnik to take over in the second half. But Khan sustained his speed, and never gave Kotelnik a chance to come on."
1. Marcos Maidana (2010-12-11)

(Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)
They said Khan wouldn't fight a puncher. Specifically, they said he wouldn't fight Marcos Maidana, considered as dangerous a puncher as there was in the 140-pound division, a reckless guy who knew no fear inside the squared circle and surely wouldn't be deterred by Khan pumping his jab and working around the ring. Somehow, Khan would find himself in a fight.
In the first round, it looked like all of that wasn't going to happen, as Maidana was floored on an absolutely wicked body shot that appeared would keep him down for the count. Wincing through the pain, Maidana somehow picked himself up, and amazingly, fought on.
Maidana made it rough, and was penalized a point in the fifth round for elbowing. Then, in the tenth round, he drilled Khan with a big right hand, shaking the Brit and sending him into retreat mode. As Maidana chased Khan around the ring, he belted him repeatedly -- but Khan stayed up, smiled, and kept moving. Khan tried to hold at one point, but couldn't get Maidana in his grasp. So he covered up, he moved, and he survived the round, and ultimately, the fight, winning by scores of 114-111, 114-111, and 113-112. The fight was named the BWAA Fight of the Year, and was indeed one of the very best of 2010.
26 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Good Fight
Peterson showed some heart in his last fight hope to him bounce back against Khan!!
You should do this for Peterson.
- might be his draw with Oritz
- Cayo
- blain??
by journeyintosound on Dec 9, 2011 8:20 AM EST reply actions
I’m not doing one for Peterson because frankly there’s not enough there.
But yes those are the top two IMO.
Bad Left Hook
"To the town of Agua Fria rode a stranger one fine day..."
not a good resume if you ask me considering he talks as if he’s cleaned out the division. it’s a lot of american fighters he can fight to put himself in that category he claims he’s in. i would like to see him fight Lucas Matthysse a hard puncher with more speed than Maidana.
by mississippi33 on Dec 9, 2011 9:25 AM EST reply actions 1 recs
Well who else would you have him fight?
Bradley? He wanted to, Tim had management issues
Alexander? I think he has proven himself to be quite…. awful tbh
Kotelnik and Maidana are very good wins in the LWW division. Who knows, if Bradley sorts himself out, that may happen early next year (Doubt it though.) Add Peterson to this, that is a solid resume at LWW
by Sweet science on Dec 9, 2011 3:07 PM EST up reply actions
Khan doesn’t have an incredible resume, but it’s not like there are a ton of guys that he has avoided in the process. BTW, just re-watched the Maidana fight the other night and had forgotten how utterly dominant he looked in the early rounds. He was touching Maidana up like nobody’s business, so if he can clean the defense up a little bit to avoid the big shots, he should be in good shape moving forward.
He sort of is what he is: a very skilled, tall, rangy boxer with quick hands, decent power, average defense, and an iffy chin. That makes him fun to watch.
You can put little asterisks beside some of Khan's wins
like McCloskey (kinda weird cut stoppage…wasn’t it a butt?), Judah (not a legal blow) and Maidana (Joe Cortez deciding that in-fighting wasn’t gonna be allowed)
but to his credit, he was winning all of those fights.
I like that Khan knows who he is and what he does best. He can’t fight at all inside, so he doesn’t. Rare poise for a young guy. And this may not be popular, but the package he brings into the ring makes me think he would have a good chance at Mayweather.
This upcoming fight with Peterson does nothing for me though. Hopefully the DC guy can make it interesting late.
Why doesn't the Peterson fight do anything for you
Peterson is as good as fight as any at LWW imo. (Bradley aside)
I don’t give Lamont a chance (10% probably) but that is because I think Khan steps it up a level, and truly opens people eyes to his talent
by Sweet science on Dec 9, 2011 3:09 PM EST up reply actions
Ducked a fighter who has not even fought at LWW. Whose best win is against Katsidis, after which he has been out with an injured shoulder (I think)
by Sweet science on Dec 9, 2011 3:52 PM EST up reply actions
Don’t quite know if you’re being a bit sarcastic here but in any event, the story goes as I recall: Amir Khan’s people called out Robert not expecting him to accept a potential fight, then Khan and his team backed out and took the easier fight with Zab Judah instead. Now, that’s the gist of the back and forth between the two fighters. Again, its one side of the story against the other but I mean how can Khan say people are ducking him when he supposedly ducked Robert? All I know is that someone ain’t telling the truth.
by Scott Harrison on Dec 9, 2011 4:32 PM EST up reply actions
Again, its one side of the story against the other
All I know is that someone ain’t telling the truth.
So you just go & make an outlandish statment such as….
Khan ducked Robert Guerrero
by Sweet science on Dec 9, 2011 4:38 PM EST up reply actions
well it was
Used some of the facts and alot of the rumours to come to a biased conclusion
by Sweet science on Dec 9, 2011 5:26 PM EST up reply actions
Your backtracking and circling when called out at all is getting artful! And very familiar.
Bad Left Hook
"To the town of Agua Fria rode a stranger one fine day..."
Khan annoys me more than most boxers but he has taken some really good fights for someone of his level. The Maidana fight was the one fight where if you were his advisers would probably tell him no way. And this fight against Peterson, I feel like it’s a no win situation for Khan. If he loses then his stock falls a lot and a win won’t help him any. I know it’s not generating any buzz in my neck of the woods (LA area), well at least not at my club. I applaud Khan for taking these fights that are very risky with little upside.
It depends on how he wins
If Peterson lasts the full 12, making Khan miss like McCloskey, it will be a huge step back (Or at least a full step to nowhere) in his ambitions for a fight with Mayweather in 2012. If he struggles with Lamont, Mayweather will crucify him.
If he stops him, and really dominates the fight, it really is a great win in his opponents backyard
by Sweet science on Dec 9, 2011 5:29 PM EST up reply actions
at the time, maidana was khan’s mandatory.
this aspect seems to be underreported to me.
it was a great fight and he showed tons of heart, but i think the main reason that fight happened is because khan didn’t want to be stripped of his title (and seen as someone who’d rather give up a title than face maidana), not than khan wanted to take on a big puncher.

by 



























