Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Win or Lose, Boston Celtics' New Big 3 Era A Success

Fight Preview: Amir Khan v. Paul McCloskey

Paul McCloskey is gunning for a star-making upset of Amir Khan on Saturday in Manchester. (Photo by Alex Livesey/Getty Images)

Sometimes, fights are doomed from the start. While Saturday's fight between Amir Khan and Paul McCloskey will still go ahead, and maybe wouldn't be classified as "doomed" since its existence isn't threatened, the fight has certainly seen its share of troubles.

Khan began searching for...well, how do you want to put it? An easier opponent? An easier opponent at home in the UK? A UK payday against an easier opponent? However you choose to phrase it, after beating Marcos Maidana in February, Khan was expected to take a step back in competition. There were flirtations between Khan and Lamont Peterson for a fight, with Peterson coming off of a tough draw against Victor Ortiz on the Khan-Maidana undercard, but in the end we wound up with Khan booked against European junior welterweight champ Paul McCloskey, a 31-year-old from Derry, Northern Ireland.

I'm not saying McCloskey is a terrible opponent. I don't think he is. All things considered, he's a perfectly acceptable opponent, especially for what we all know was intended to be a UK money fight for Khan, a "homecoming" of sorts after spending his entire 2010 fighting in the United States, conquering Malignaggi and Maidana.

But if Khan expected to receive some massive hero's welcome, he got a reality check. When a decent co-feature attraction fell through twice, Sky Sports decided to pull the event from their PPV service, Sky Box Office. This was reported to have cost Khan upwards of £1 million. Sky offered to put the fight on Sky Sports 3, but an agreement could not be reached, so the major sports and boxing broadcaster in the UK pulled the plug on their support.

Scrambling, Khan-McCloskey was sent to another UK PPV carrier, Primetime. There still isn't much of an undercard, not by UK viewer standards anyway. I've seen some UK fans call the £14.95 pricetag "shocking" for this event.

But it is what it is, and the fight is going forward. So let's talk about the fight.

Star-divide

I said a moment ago that McCloskey is not a bad opponent. I'll stand by that. I also don't think he has much shot of winning this fight. McCloskey (22-0, 12 KO) has stopped his last five opponents, but I don't think I'm knocking anyone unnecessarily when I say that Colin Lynes, Dean Harrison, Daniel Rasilla, Giuseppe Lauri and Barry Morrison are hardly on Khan's level.

Sure, Khan (24-1, 17 KO) has been knocked cold before. But to get knocked cold, Khan was caught cold by a guy with a pretty big right. Breidis Prescott is nothing more than a mediocre brawler when you get right down to it, but he landed big shots on Khan, and landed them clean. Khan wasn't knocked down or stopped when he got caught by Marcos Maidana in December, and McCloskey doesn't have the big power of either Maidana or Prescott.

I don't mean to sound insulting or dismissive when I say this, but this fight reminds me a lot more of Khan-Dmitriy Salita than it does Khan-Prescott or Khan-Maidana. At best, this fight might look like Khan-Malignaggi. McCloskey is not a special fighter, just a credible fighter. He's good, but is nowhere near Khan's class of talent.

As such, I'm having a really hard time seeing anything more than Khan using his excellent speed and ever-improving at-range offense to batter McCloskey into a stoppage. McCloskey has not seen speed -- and the power that comes from such speed -- like this before in his pro career, and I expect him to find himself a bit taken aback, even overwhelmed. Khan fought like he had something to prove against Maidana, or to put it another way, Khan fought recklessly and at times a bit stupidly against Maidana. I don't think he's trying to prove anything against McCloskey. He's established now. He's coming to fight and to win, and to do so convincingly, I don't think he'll have to do anything more than use what God and Freddie Roach (not necessarily in that order) have given him. Pick: Amir Khan TKO-7

The Undercard: Quick Glance From an American

Super bantamweight contender Rendall Munroe (21-2, 9 KO) should beat Andrei Isaeu (23-2, 7 KO) in his Hatton Promotions debut, but it won't surprise me if "The Boxing Bin Man" has some trouble. Isaeu has been a (very, very) fringe contender at featherweight for a little while now, and it's a decent return for Munroe, who hasn't fought since his October loss to Toshiaki Nishioka. ... British welterweight champion Craig Watson (20-3, 8 KO) should handle Lee Purdy (14-2-1, 7 KO) without much trouble. The 23-year-old Purdy does have youth on his side. ... Middleweight Martin Murray (21-0, 8 KO) has never much impressed me. His opponent, John Anderson Carvalho (21-4-1, 11 KO) has the distinction of being Brazil's best middleweight. He was knocked out in two by Gennady Golovkin and lost a virtual shutout to Sebastian Zbik, and it was legit scoring. ... Gary Buckland (21-2, 8 KO) returns from his November Prizefighter win to face Rafael Hernandez (13-3-1, 11 KO) in super featherweight action. Hernandez is a Venezuelan fighting in the UK for the first time, though he has fought in Mexico, Panama, Colombia and Thailand before.

Comment 7 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Nice review……..I know little of McCloskey, but he’s undefeated, Euro champ, and maybe the N. Ireland v England angle may give us a good fight.

by DPlainview on Apr 14, 2011 9:38 AM EDT reply actions  

Any chance that McCloskey could pull a Prescott?

by cyke on Apr 14, 2011 1:04 PM EDT reply actions  

No.

"I live what you talk. I Live What You Talk.'’ (Bernard Hopkins)

by BrianBrock on Apr 14, 2011 1:26 PM EDT up reply actions  

I'm really not a fan of McCloskey

I don’t see him having any chance, his game is to outskill and outspeed his opponents and he’ll be at a heavy disadvantage in both those areas against Khan. I don’t see much difference between this bout and Khan v Salita, I think McCloskey is going to struggle mightily with Khan’s speed and I can’t envisage a situation in which he sees out the full 12. Also, interesting to read how Tris Dixon slaughtered Khan’s team for their part in this in BN today.. wonder how the relationship between Khan and Sky will go on from here.

by LtfcPete on Apr 14, 2011 2:32 PM EDT reply actions  

Yeah

i read that.
Khan has made a bad move here with the Primetime thing it seems.
I’m suprised not many have mentioned that McCloskey is often a counter puncher and i think he will be looking to time Khan when he throws his combo’s.
It’s a big ask though and i doubt he’ll land many but you never know.McCloskey is more skilled than some are giving him credit for (not referring to this preview) and can generate quite a bit of power in his snealy shots but i’m sure he’s not on or even near Khan’s level.Speed (and skills)will surely kill.
BTW,it’s interesting to me that Khan has made two pretty big decisions recently that could have some bearing on his future both in the ring and outside:Sacking Alex Ariza and moving this card to Primetime.
1/ Is his new conditioning coach as good as Ariza as a lot of Amir’s stamina and strength where clearly partly due to Ariza’s training methods?
2/ As Pete mentioned above Khan could now have damaged his relationship with Sky when he moved over to Primetime and his father and Asif Vali or whoever is advising him really made a bad move here,imo.
The Primetime audience will likely be small and probably mostly made up of Irish and Pakistani fans based in the UK and a few boxing diehards.
If he had stayed with Sky Sports 3 he may or may not have got more or less money but he would have got much more exposure and very likely more PPV buys for the proposed Tim Bradley fight.
He should have looked at the long term here.

by Matt Mosley on Apr 14, 2011 2:50 PM EDT up reply actions  

McCloskey is a few steps up in class from Salita, IMO

But he’s closer to Salita than Maidana, and even if he doesn’t get knocked out early, he just doesn’t have the style or the talent to trouble Khan much.

Bad Left Hook - The SB Nation boxing blog
"Baseball is played on the field, not on a calculator."

by Brickhaus on Apr 14, 2011 4:19 PM EDT up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Zoom_2_small
Ward needs to leave SM, and SM needs him to leave
Reds_small
Ray Robinson And Cassius Clay, Together For The First Time
Buchanan
David Price and Seth Mitchell: How to Properly Develop a Heavyweight
Small
Sterioids in Boxing!!
Ali-frazier_small
Aaron Pryor vs Floyd Mayweather.
017_small
Adrien Broner - Real or Imitation
Small
Press Release: Top Rank purchases WBC
Buchanan
Is Boxing Dead?
Singleton04_small
It's Not if but When, they're fires stop burning
Reds_small
A Few Ballroom Bout Results

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editor

206480_10150226708710923_747385922_9037192_4017321_n_small Scott Christ

Editors & Moderators

Aki_hair_cropped_small Brickhaus

Boxing_icon_small Matt Miller

Profile_picture_small Brent Brookhouse

Ingo_small A.F.

Contributors

Henry_leeds_small Oli Goldstein

Chris_celletti_headshot_small Chris Celletti

Duran4-470x308_small Kory Kitchen

051_small Thomas Hill