With Amir Khan vs Timothy Bradley Off, Who's the Best Opponent for Khan?
Dan Rafael of ESPN.com reports the news most everyone was expecting, as the Wednesday deadline to make a July 23 fight between Amir Khan and Timothy Bradley has come and gone, with no deal struck between the parties. Now, Khan and Golden Boy Promotions move on, seeking a new opponent for the same date.
The candidates, as discussed before, are as follows:
- Marcos Maidana (30-2, 27 KO): Maidana had Khan in real trouble late in their December fight, and the bout went down to the wire and won the BWAA Fight of the Year award. Maidana last fought on April 9, taking home a tougher-than-expected win over Erik Morales. Scott Score on Khan-Maidana II: 9/10. The first fight was great and close on the cards, and in my view this is the more relevant Maidana rematch, between Khan and Morales.
- Robert Guerrero (29-1-1, 18 KO): 28-year-old Guerrero says he's ready to step up his competition. He seems to most desire a fight with lightweight world champ Juan Manuel Marquez, but has said he's ready to move up to 140 or even 147 pounds if need be. Guerrero's name has been connected to Khan, Victor Ortiz and even Floyd Mayweather. Scott Score on Khan-Guerrero: 7/10. It's a good fight -- a really good fight, even. But it isn't great. I do think someone with Guerrero's skills is a danger to Khan, and I also would say it's time to stop considering Guerrero to be "inconsistent." Though he was lazy last year against shot Joel Casamayor, he's been dominant in recent wins over solid foes Michael Katsidis and Vicente Escobedo. He seems to step it up when the opponents are legit.
- Erik Morales (51-7, 35 KO): I'll admit that Morales' comeback starting last year has gone better than I expected. He beat a few decent opponents (none great or even good, but no bums) and then was crazy brave against Maidana. Morales is currently scheduled to fight on HBO PPV on July 30, so moving him up a week and reaching a wider audience should work. Scott Score on Khan-Morales: 3/10. Though the 34-year-old Morales stunned many by being so competitive and gutsy in his loss to Maidana, he's still really a blown-up super bantamweight, and he's old and shop-worn. And Khan's height and speed advantages won't allow Morales to so easily dip into his bag of tricks for solutions to solve the opponent's puzzle.
- Zab Judah (41-6, 28 KO): Whatever your opinion on the subject (and no, I really, really, really don't want to hear it either way), Judah getting religion seems to have made him a legitimately changed man. And the move back down to 140 pounds has been good for him, too. Judah has won five in a row since beginning to work his way back down to junior welterweight. Scott Score on Khan-Judah: 6/10. It's fine. This is not, in my opinion, as good a fight as Khan-Guerrero because I don't think Judah's as good as Guerrero anymore. But Zab has a fanbase and generally his fights are fun to watch. Plus with whatever speed he does have left, and his southpaw stance, he could give Khan some new looks -- wait, Khan spars with Manny Pacquiao. Make that 5/10.
10 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Interesting.
- Khan can always go the Pacquiao route and choose Erik Morales. Not only is Morales a draw with the Mexican fans — as is Khan with his own crowd — but Pacquiao has beaten him. Khan can always say he beat Morales worse than Pacquiao did. Apparently this forumla works. Low risk – High reward.
- Robert Gurrero is a risk, but this type of fight could really show the versatility of both men. However, a loss to Gurerro would kill Khan’s current build-up and he cannot risk another Breidis Prescott-esque loss.
Personally, Khan vs Maidana 2 would be my second choice, but overall I like Khan-Judah the best. I have always been a fan of Judah, however, his skills may have diminished slightly, but they haven’t deteriorated to the point where he couldn’t give Khan a good fight.
Floyd Mayweather, Jr. fan since 7/12/97 — 41-0-0 (25 KOs)
Boxing TOP 5: Mayweather, Donaire, S. Martinez, JM Marquez, M. Cotto
MMA TOP 5: A. Silva, Hendo, Rampage, Bones, Nick Diaz
K-1 TOP 5: Overeem, Jienotsu, Masato, Buakaw, Zambidis
I dunno, I would prefer to see Guerrero establish himself at 140 before going for a Khan fight (honestly I’d like to see him stay at lightweight and fight Marquez and Rios, but I know that’s a pipedream). I simply have no idea if he could make Khan respect his punches at this weight. I’m inclined to agree that he’s a better pound-for-pound fighter than Judah right now, but I think Zab’s handspeed and power would make for a more compelling match at the moment.
I think a Maidana rematch would follow the path of the first fight but maybe less entertaining. That said Id watch it. A Guerrero fight is interesting but I think Khan beats him convincingly, lightweight is were Id like to see him for now. My first choice would be a Judah fight. It would give a different fight for Khan than what the others can offer
"A hero has faced it all: he need not be undefeated, but he must be undaunted." - Andrew Bernstein
I don't know why
But I like Judah for this. I would actually be ok with any of those fights. Morales would be last on the list though.
Either a Maidana rematch or Guerrero—the first Maidana fight was close, and altho’ rematches are often not as good, with Maidana in the mix how can it be a boring fight? Re Guerrero, it seems like a risky fight for both of them, which could lead to a very tentative fight, or a really, really, good one. I’m too squeamish for Morales’s sake, which may not be giving him enough credit, but I’d like for him to thrive.
There is no safety in numbers, or in anything else--James Thurber, 1939
He’s already booked for 6/25.
Bad Left Hook
"To the town of Agua Fria rode a stranger one fine day..."
by Scott Christ on May 5, 2011 11:04 AM EDT up reply actions
I have a hard time seeing them pick Morales unless HBO isn’t keen on a Morales PPV for 7/30. Makes no sense to leave money for a Morales PPV on the table to have him lose to Khan a week earlier in a fight that won’t even have much credibility among the audience that would watch it.
Bad Left Hook
"To the town of Agua Fria rode a stranger one fine day..."
by Scott Christ on May 5, 2011 12:33 PM EDT up reply actions
Judah or Maidana
would be the best options for me.
I think there’s more chance of Khan fighting Sergio Martinez than there is him getting in with Maidana again but who knows,maybe his confidence will be up after seeing what Morales did against him.

by 


























