clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Bad Left Hook Boxing Rankings (May 28, 2019): Herring crashes 130, Canizales moves up at 108

Jamel Herring is new in the 130 top 10, while Carlos Canizales made a statement at 108 this past week.

Ryoichi Taguchi v Carlos Canizales - WBA World Light Flyweight Title Bout Photo by Matt Roberts/Getty Images
Scott Christ is the managing editor of Bad Left Hook and has been covering boxing for SB Nation since 2006.

Rankings will be posted each Tuesday at Noon ET.

This week’s ranked fights:

  • Heavyweight: (1) Anthony Joshua vs (10) Andy Ruiz Jr, June 1 (DAZN)
  • Super Middleweight: (1) Callum Smith vs Hassan N’Dam, June 1 (DAZN)
  • Super Flyweight: (10) Francisco Rodriguez Jr vs David Barreto, June 1
  • Strawweight: (1) Wanheng Menayothin vs (9) Tatsuya Fukuhara, May 31

Upcoming Fights: (1) Anthony Joshua vs (10) Andy Ruiz Jr, June 1 ... (2) Tyson Fury vs Tom Schwarz, June 15 ... (4) Dillian Whyte vs (8) Oscar Rivas, July 20

Upcoming Fights: (7) Junior Makabu vs Mike Perez, June 8 ... (8) Kevin Lerena vs Vasil Ducar, June 8 ... (2) Mairis Briedis vs (4) Krzysztof Glowacki, June 15 ... (5) Yunier Dorticos vs (9) Andrew Tabiti, June 15

Upcoming Fights: (8) Sullivan Barrera vs Jesse Hart, June 15 ... (2) Sergey Kovalev vs Anthony Yarde, June 29 ... (5) Marcus Browne vs Jean Pascal, August 3

Upcoming Fights: (1) Callum Smith vs Hassan N’dam, June 1 ... (4) Jesse Hart vs Sullivan Barrera [175], June 15 ... (3) Caleb Plant vs Mike Lee, July 20

Upcoming Fights: (2) Gennadiy Golovkin vs Steve Rolls, June 8 ... (4) Demetrius Andrade vs (9) Maciej Sulecki, June 29 ... (6) Jermall Charlo vs Brandon Adams, June 29 ... (7) Rob Brant vs (8) Ryota Murata, July 12 ... (1) Canelo Alvarez vs TBA, Sept. 14

Notes: I was pretty much high man on ranking Austin Trout before this past weekend, but with his draw against Terrell Gausha, which really should have been a loss, he drops out of the top 10. So the question was about the new No. 10 man in the division. I considered Gausha, of course, but while I think Gausha did enough to beat Trout, it was really more one of those “did enough” things than it was anything like Gausha being so much greater than previously imagined. I also considered Liam Smith, a reliable contender in the division in recent years. And I considered European champ Sergio Garcia, too, and Erickson Lubin and Carlos Adames. But I settled for now on Kell Brook, the former welterweight titleholder who wasn’t impressive last time out against Michael Zerafa but did win with no question. Brook’s immediate future may be back at 147, but for now he ranks at 154, where his last two fights have taken place. I really came down to Brook or Sergio Garcia, and as good a technician as Garcia looked against Ted Cheeseman in February, I am more skeptical about that win (maybe Cheeseman just isn’t very good yet) than I am about Brook having a bit of an off-night in December. If it came down to it and a Brook-Garcia fight got made, I think I’d pick Brook to win, even if I’d think Garcia a live dog. Lubin and Adames are stalking the list, though. I didn’t write Lubin off with the loss to Jermell Charlo, he’s still really young, and he’s got a world title eliminator next, albeit not against a top opponent.

Upcoming Fights: (5) Tony Harrison vs (6) Jermell Charlo, June 23

Upcoming Fights: (3) Manny Pacquiao vs (4) Keith Thurman, July 20 ... (7) Yordenis Ugas vs Omar Figueroa Jr, July 20 ... (8) Sergey Lipinets vs John Molina Jr, July 20

Upcoming Fights: (3) Maurice Hooker vs TBA, July 27 ... (1) Regis Prograis vs (2) Josh Taylor, TBA

Notes: I know it was just Antonio Lozada Jr, who had his moments here and there in the fight, but I flipped Jose Pedraza and Robert Easter Jr based not just on Pedraza’s win over Lozada on Saturday, but when I thought about that fight and Pedraza’s decent effort against Lomachenko in December, then thought about the last handful of times we’ve seen Easter — I dunno, I just think Pedraza deserves the slightly higher rank right now. This is the sort of thing I really mean when I say my rankings will have more week-to-week movement than some might. I’m not going to keep things static just because I thought that way before. If something changes my mind, I’ll make a change in the rankings. Boxing changes fast. I was once really high on Easter, and that enthusiasm probably peaked after his April 2016 stoppage of Argenis Mendez, who three years later is still a pretty good fighter. But I haven’t come out of a fight really impressed with Easter since his Sept. 2016 win over Richard Commey, either. His title reign was really pedestrian, Mikey Garcia outclassed him worse than Loma did Pedraza, and last time out with Barthelemy, the two of them were awful. Just awful. I’m not saying they’re bad fighters — obviously, I still have them both ranked here — but it was a fight where two good fighters made each other look dreadful, and a lot of that was neither of them had the willingness to take a risk, both of them all but begging for a draw, which they got.

Upcoming Fights: (3) Richard Commey vs (10) Ray Beltran, June 28 ... (9) Teofimo Lopez vs Masayoshi Nakatani, July 19 ... (1) Vasiliy Lomachenko vs (4) Luke Campbell, TBA

Notes: I picked Herring to get the win over Ito last week on a feeling that he had the right tools and Brian McIntyre would have the right plan against a good, basic fighter. If he faces Berchelt next as was the hype coming in, that’s a much tougher test. For as much as the ESPN broadcast crew hyped some ferocious power from Ito, they were talking about a guy with a 52% KO rate who didn’t exactly blast out Christopher Diaz the last time he was on their airwaves. Meanwhile they had Tessitore screaming about Ito as if Ito were one Tommy Hearns right hand away from erasing all of Herring’s good work. Anyway, I do think Ito still deserves a top 10 slot here, but like most fighters — even most good ones — he has his limitations and bad style matchups, and Herring and McIntyre executed on Saturday. As for Herring, the moves to 130 and the new trainer have suited him. McIntyre is proving himself to not just be some guy who was lucky enough to hook up with Terence Crawford, and I thought Herring looked sharp his first couple times out moving down in weight, and he proved that was no illusion of lesser competition. Jamel has worked and fought his way to his spot.

Upcoming Fights: (4) Andrew Cancio vs (5) Alberto Machado, June 21 ... (3) Gervonta Davis vs Ricardo Nunez, July 27 ... (2) Tevin Farmer vs Guillaume Frenois, TBA

Notes: No movement this week, but I did weigh maybe switching Galahad and Xu at the 9/10 slots. Xu looked really good stopping Shun Kubo, a former 122-pound titleholder, on Sunday, and is on a nice streak overall, with two pretty good wins this year. But I figure the Galahad thing will sort it in a couple of weeks when Galahad faces Josh Warrington. Also, on another note, Abner Mares will be one-year “inactive” soon (June 9), but I’m not going to drop him unless he officially retires, which at last update he does not plan to do. He would have fought in February, though at 130, if not for the eye injury. He’s kind of in a wait-and-see spot at the moment. I’m just saying I’m not going to be a stickler for the one-year thing because boxing is weird and so many variables come into play with these situations. Mares plans to fight as of his most recent statements.

Upcoming Fights: (4) Oscar Valdez vs Jason Sanchez, June 8 ... (2) Josh Warrington vs (9) Kid Galahad, June 15 ... (8) Shakur Stevenson vs TBA, July 13

Upcoming Fights: (4) Guillermo Rigondeaux vs Julio Ceja, June 23 ... (1) Rey Vargas vs (8) Tomoki Kameda, July 13 ... (2) Daniel Roman vs Murodjon Akhmadaliev, TBA

Upcoming Fights: (8) Jason Moloney vs Cesar Ramirez, June 15 ... (6) Nordine Oubaali vs TBA, July 6 ... (2) Luis Nery vs TBA, July 20 ... (1) Naoya Inoue vs (3) Nonito Donaire, TBA

Upcoming Fights: (10) Francisco Rodriguez Jr vs David Barreto, June 1 ... (8) Andrew Moloney vs Ruben Montoya, June 15 ... (6) Kazuto Ioka vs (9) Aston Palicte, June 19 ... (7) Kal Yafai vs Norbelto Jimenez, TBA

Notes: The change here is that Sho Kimura moved down in weight, so Ryoichi Taguchi moves in at No. 10 for now. He’s lost two in a row, but they were to Hekkie Budler in a narrow decision at 108, and then to Kosei Tanaka in March where Taguchi still looked like he had plenty of fire, he just wasn’t good enough to beat the top guy in the division. My debate for the open spot came down to Taguchi or 21-year-old Japanese flyweight titleholder Junto Nakatani, who is unbeaten and promising but not as proven in victory as Taguchi has been in recent defeats.

Upcoming Fights: (3) Artem Dalakian vs Dennapa Kiatniwat, June 15

Notes: Bumped Carlos Canizales a couple spots for a really strong, impressive win on Sunday in China over Sho Kimura, who was coming down from 112 and also moves into these rankings at No. 8. (He was No. 5 last week at flyweight.) Kimura may well move right back up, but for now he’ll rank here. If it changes later, it changes later. Canizales unquestionably won, but I think Kimura is still better than the guys below him at 108.

Upcoming Fights: (2) Hiroto Kyoguchi vs Satanmuanglek CP Freshmart, June 19 ... (3) Angel Acosta vs Elwin Soto, June 21

Upcoming Fights: (1) Wanheng Menayothin vs (9) Tatsuya Fukuhara, May 31

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Bad Left Hook Daily Roundup newsletter!

A daily roundup of all your global boxing news from Bad Left Hook