clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Spence vs Porter: Top takeaways from a strong PPV main event

New, comments

We know who’s next for Errol Spence Jr, but there’s a lot to unpack for Spence and Shawn Porter after Saturday’s rumble.

Errol Spence Jr. v Shawn Porter Photo by Jayne Kamin-Oncea/Getty Images

Assumptions were made and worries shared that this one wouldn’t provide great bang for the buck, mostly because there was no shortage of folks who thought Errol Spence would exert his version of “The Truth” on Shawn Porter, and that would result in Porter, the gritty rumbler with the fullback mentality, being dropped and stopped Saturday evening in LA.

Didn’t happen. Assumptions often do and did again make an “ass” of “me” and “u.” And as for the bang, people got their money’s worth in what played out as something in the Fight of the Year-type realm for some peeps.

Here are top takeaways from the welterweight unification held last night at Staples Center, which screened on FOX PPV.

—Shawn Porter (30-3-1, 17 KO) is to be respected. Indeed, he has some losses on his ledger, and he snagged an L against Spence (26-0, 21 KO) here, but his legacy won’t be based on his win-loss ratio. Positive traits, like willingness and desire to always be fighting the best foe, A-grade stamina, ultra-durable chin and yep, ring generalship, are his to boast of when he makes it into the Hall of Fame. The way he showed all that he’s not just a fullback sort, that he can dance in between the tackles, and make it hard for a foe to find and hit him...I found myself lauding him mentally after every damn round of the 12 elapsed at Staples. His stock popped, despite him taking on his third L.

—Sorry not sorry, to perseverate on the “loser.” Try and recall this the next time you are assessing a prizefight, and offering your take on what is likely to occur. Porter has a chin that is as good as it gets — the short left hook that clipped him in round 11 would have made a crumpled heap of most men. Porter, it just buckled his legs, and he almost keep them so sturdy underneath, but his glove touched canvas, and so Spence got a 10-8 11th. Two judges (Rey Danseco and Steve Weisfeld) scored it 116-111 Spence, while Larry Hazzard Jr gave Porter bountiful love, seeing it 115-112 for the Ohio native. But point being here, the “power” guy, you will want to caution yourself that power doesn’t always show itself equally in every fight, and that’s because people have different grades of chins, and defense matters. In Super Bowls, and prizefights, defense matters. Chin and (still underrated D) gave Porter a real good chance to snag Spences’ IBF belt.

—This piece is turning into a Porter homage; so be it. The class Porter showed after, how admirable. He asked the crowd if they were entertained, and, amazingly, to me, didn’t whine or focus on the scorecards. What a role model! He went there to do his best, entertain those gathered to watch, get paid — all those things were in his control realm. How the judges might see was not, so he didn’t lose sleep on harp on that. ROLE MODEL.

--The 29-year-old Spence is still a work in progress, at 29. Wait, what? Yep; he hasn’t fought the caliber of folks that Porter has, and you can be certain this win was a learning experience for him. How to pace oneself during a fight like this, against an A-tier guy, how and when to consider modifications in strategy during a bout, him and trainer Derrick James will be heading to the gym and not just repeating their prep for the next one, but looking to consider some tweaks. He termed his effort “sloppy” in the ring, talking to Hedi Androl, a quote that many folks missed. Makes some sense, his continued learning curve maybe; he fought once in 2017, twice in 2018, and one of those was versus a B- pro, and once in 2019 before this go. Spence’s activity rate is regular for this era for the top tenners/PPV guys, but more tangoes against higher grade people would have forced him to consider his arsenal and methods in a 360 degrees manner.

—You can do worse than check out promoter Lou DiBella’s post-fight take. His skills at assessment are top tier.

Now, I throw it to you. Did you change your take on what a Spence versus Bud Crawford fight would look like, after seeing Spence not manhandle Porter, and be the first man to stop the Ohio native? Or nah, because you realize styles make fights, and you are thinking that Crawford hasn’t been touched by someone with the power caliber of Errol? Or maybe you think Bud is a full notch better at pugilism than anyone Errol has met, and this cemented that notion to you.

Along those lines, you best be ready to keep marinating those thoughts. Indications are that Spence is staying on the PBC side of the street for a while longer. You saw Danny Garcia escorted into the ring, and get announced as Spence’s next foe, date and site TBA. It looks and feels like all the meaningful/logical intra-PBC fights will have to get made before the powers that be (aka Al Haymon) will decide that Spence and Crawford should square off.

Me, I will put in my two cents, and say it should be done now, while both are in their prime, and it is obviously the one that the fans want next, judging by the harsh response from a majority of fight fans on social media who believe Garcia is not really deserving of a Spence fight.

Terence Crawford v Amir Khan Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images

That may or may not be, but I won’t pretend I don’t think kicking this can down the road to 2021 isn’t the wrong move. Right move, arguably, from a business standpoint, but why risk one of them gets knocked off, as Anthony Joshua did — and building brands to make the money pot fatter is an exercise in Hyper Capitalism 101. Makes sense for a narrow few sharing in the revenue pie, but not so much sense outside of that.

Want boxing to survive and thrive? Have the best fight the best in a timely fashion, and old fans will applaud and new ones will come to the table, and stay a while. Get too fine with your mission, and you risk alienating old fans and you do what the sports’ power brokers have done time and again: you lose the opportunity to grow the sport’s eyeballs base. We have a stagnant fan base, we aren’t winning new fans like, arguably, we could be doing, and that’s largely because more fighters need the Porter mentality (wanting and demanding to fight the best foes) and business matters take precedence over common sense old-school values (have the best fighting the best) way too often.

—What do you all think about a rematch? Wasn’t hearing the call for that. Would it not make sense? Porter was asked if he thought he won the fight in the post-fight presser, and he pondered that long and hard. He’d have to watch the fight, he stated.

“For me to say that was a robbery, you’re not gonna hear me say that,” he shared. Father-trainer Kenny Porter said, “We want all the rematches!”

It is clear that there is still emotion in the air, which would help fuel a sequel. Porter and Spence went at it at the post-fight, squabbling over who was the better PPV driver.

“I’m pretty sure I’m the one that sold this pay per view,” said Porter, after Spence said that Terence Crawford hasn’t proved to be a PPV draw, and “he needs me more than I need him.”

They sparred, hard.

“You a man with no land, you a man with no land,” said the Texan.

Porter said he worked harder to promote this card.

“You not gonna be on PPV after this,” said Spence. “You would not fighting on pay per view if not for me. What arena can you sell out by yourself?”

Publicist Kelly Swanson then threw cold water on the dust up, and called for an end to the fracas, not sure why. Me, I liked that there was still animus in the air, and it led me to this place: Why the hell not book a rematch for their next rumble? This scrap was great, we know now how the styles match up, and I could almost promise a sequel would also be stellar. But, this is boxing, we do tend to overcomplicate matters, right?

Talk to me. What are your top takeaways from #SpencePorter?