clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Bad Left Hook Boxing Rankings (Jan. 21, 2020): Jeison Rosario upset sends shockwaves through 154-pound division

The junior middleweight division has gone topsy-turvy after Jeison Rosario’s big upset over Julian Williams.

Julian Williams v Jeison Rosario Photo by Corey Perrine/Getty Images
Scott Christ is the managing editor of Bad Left Hook and has been covering boxing for SB Nation since 2006.

Rankings will be posted each Tuesday at Noon ET.

Ranked fights this week:

  • Junior Middleweight: (4) Jarrett Hurd vs Francisco Santana, Jan. 25
  • Welterweight: (6) Danny Garcia vs Ivan Redkach, Jan. 25

Upcoming Fights: (1) Tyson Fury vs (2) Deontay Wilder, Feb. 22

Upcoming Fights: (4) Ilunga Makabu vs (7) Michal Cieslak, Jan. 31 ... (5) Kevin Lerena vs Firat Arslan, Feb. 8 ... (1) Mairis Briedis vs (2) Yuniel Dorticos, Mar. 21

Notes: We had a discussion about Eleider Alvarez’ standing in the division during Saturday night’s card, where he knocked out Michael Seals. One of you felt it was unreasonable that Alvarez is ranked behind Jean Pascal, whom Alvarez defeated pretty soundly back in 2017. I agree there’s certainly an argument to have Alvarez as high as No. 5, and I thought on this after the fight, because I’m always up to reexamine, and I came to the conclusion it’s probably the right thing. I always say boxing rankings can’t just stay static, you have to constantly observe. Guys can’t be in one spot just because they haven’t recently lost. Maybe they should have. Maybe a fight was tougher than expected. Lots of things. Alvarez dropped the way he did for losing to Kovalev, but he also had an Achilles injury going into that fight, and came back looking fine this week. Seals is just Seals, but Alvarez does have a win over Pascal head-to-head, and does have a 1-1 record against Kovalev, while Pascal is an ugly 0-2 against the Russian. Pascal has done more recently, but then you have to consider HOW good a fluky win over Marcus Browne was, and HOW good a narrow win over Badou Jack was, and the fact Browne was ranked so highly for beating Jack, etc. Weighing it all out I came to the belief that Alvarez deserves to be at No. 5, a spot ahead of Pascal.

Upcoming Fights: (1) Artur Beterbiev vs Meng Fanlong, TBA

Upcoming Fights: (4) Caleb Plant vs Vincent Feigenbutz, Feb. 15 ... (3) Canelo Alvarez vs TBA, May 2

Upcoming Fights: (3) Demetrius Andrade vs Luke Keeler, Jan. 30 ... (2) Gennadiy Golovkin vs Kamil Szeremeta, Mar. 28 ... (1) Canelo Alvarez vs TBA, May 2

Notes: And here’s the big mess of a topic for the week, what the hell to do with the 154-pound division. On the “static” front, I pretty quickly decided that Jermell Charlo was the new No. 1 for our rankings, and here’s why: if he’d gotten the decision most of us felt he deserved over Tony Harrison in Dec. 2018, this would not even be a debate. He got the rematch and finished in that fight. He proved his superiority, I think, with due respect to Harrison who fought a tough fight. If he had never lost to Harrison — which again most of us didn’t think he deserved to — he probably would’ve been sitting No. 1 or No. 2 already, and the jump wouldn’t seem so big.

The reality is, all these top six guys are separated by barely anything right now, and Harrison isn’t far off of them, either. Williams was No. 1 last week, and a fifth round TKO loss to an unranked (by anyone) Jeison Rosario seems like it should drop him further, but how? He beat Hurd last year, clean and clear, fair and square. Hurd beat Lara. Lara drew with Castano. I think what I’ve come up with here is fair; Charlo stakes a claim at the top, Rosario comes from the fringes all the way to No. 2, and Nos. 3 through 6, maybe even 7, are separated by very little. This is a talented division, everyone listed here can fight and there’s a few more guys who aren’t bad, either. But none of them have proven dominant. In its way, it’s pretty damn fun. And I do think you could put Rosario in at No. 1 given the state of things, by the way, but I had a tough time giving the top spot to a guy who’s been stopped by Nathaniel Gallimore. That said, he’s the youngest of this group by a good margin.

Upcoming Fights: (4) Jarrett Hurd vs Francisco Santana, Jan. 25 ... (9) Kell Brook vs Mark DeLuca, Feb. 8

Upcoming Fights: (6) Danny Garcia vs Ivan Redkach, Jan. 25 ... (7) Yordenis Ugas vs Mike Dallas Jr, Feb. 1

Upcoming Fights: (2) Jose Ramirez vs (6) Viktor Postol, Feb. 1

Upcoming Fights: (1) Vasiliy Lomachenko vs (2) Teofimo Lopez, TBA ... (4) Luke Campbell vs (7) Javier Fortuna, TBA ... (10) Lee Selby vs George Kambosos Jr, TBA

Upcoming Fights: (3) Tevin Farmer vs (7) Joseph Diaz Jr, Jan. 30 ... (9) Masayuki Ito vs Yongqiang Yang, Feb. 1

Upcoming Fights: (2) Gary Russell Jr vs (4) Tugstsogt Nyambayar, Feb. 8 ... (6) Kid Galahad vs (9) Claudio Marrero, Feb. 8 ... (10) Ryan Walsh vs TBA, Feb. 21 ... (3) Shakur Stevenson vs Miguel Marriaga, Mar. 14

Upcoming Fights: (2) Daniel Roman vs (10) Murodjon Akhmadaliev, Jan. 30 ... (4) Guillermo Rigondeaux vs Liborio Solis [bantamweight], Feb. 8 ... (3) Emanuel Navarrete vs Jeo Tupas Santisima, Feb. 22

Upcoming Fights: (1) Naoya Inoue vs TBA, Apr. 25 ... (3) Nordine Oubaali vs (4) Nonito Donaire, TBA

Upcoming Fights: (6) Roman Gonzalez vs (7) Kal Yafai, Feb. 29

Upcoming Fights: (4) Artem Dalakian vs Josber Perez, Feb. 8 ... (3) Julio Cesar Martinez vs Jay Harris, Feb. 29

Upcoming Fights: (7) Sho Kimura vs Merlito Sabillo, Feb. 15

Upcoming Fights: (4) Wilfredo Mendez vs Pedro Villegas, Feb. 8

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for the Bad Left Hook Daily Roundup newsletter!

A daily roundup of all your global boxing news from Bad Left Hook